Post by SheldonPost by Dave SmithPost by Bob (this one)Recipes aren't absolute. They're guides. But you still have to know the
directions or you get lost. But the issue that led to this note was
Sheldon's insistence that *only* volume measure was rational. And that
*only* volume measure was THE standard.
Pathetic isn't it. Here is a guy who claims to have been a professional.
Military recipes like most all institutional recipes list ingredient
weights, but NOT for the cook, the weights are given for accounting
purposes ONLY.
Sorry. No. The cookbook recipes indicate weights and the notes say, "The
amount specified for each ingredient is comparable to its weight and
should be used only when scales for weighing are not available. More
accurate results can be expected if the ingredients can be weighed
instead of measured."
Very simple. Not for accounting; for cooking.
Post by SheldonMonthly menus are made up by the chief commissaryman and
submitted to the supply officer... the listed recipe weights are used
to calculate inventory and factoring cost ONLY. In fact there are NO
SCALES of any kind in US Navy galleys, no need as provisions are
supplied in standardized weights/volumes to facilitate the typical
recipes.
And yet, the recipes in the U.S. Navy cookbook disagree with that. All
recipes are for 100 portions.
Baking powder biscuits and short cake = 14 pounds flour
Coffee cake = 5 pounds flour
Apple torte = 5 pounds 8 ounces
dumplings = 6 pounds
Gingerbread = 7 pounds 8 ounces
Meat pie crust = 6 pounds 12 ounces
What standard size packages are these?
Post by SheldonHardly anything is measured, most all ingredients are used by
the full case, can, sackful, crate, etc... once brought to the galley
and opened the entire amount is used (nothing goes back to the storage
lockers, if not used in 12 hours it goes to Davey Jones'locker), ie.
flour is supplied in 10lb bags, six to a sack, whereas recipes use a
number of ten pound bags (no need to weigh/measure, weight is already
marked on the bag (10lbs, DUH), whereas when 5lbs is needed a 10lb bag
is sliced in half with a bakers bench knife (WOP, yup, that's the
sound, WOP!), that's as close to measuring as it gets,
And yet, the recipes in the U.S. Navy cookbook disagree with that. All
recipes are for 100 portions.
Whole wheat griddle cakes = 8 pounds flour
corn griddle cakes = 6 pounds 12 ounces
muffins = 9 pounds
molasses bran muffins = 4 pounds
Perhaps when the results don't matter and the cook doesn't care about
the results no measuring takes place. But anywhere food is produced,
particularly volume production, there are measures used. Period.
Post by Sheldonwhich is no
different from how flour is measured at typical neighborhood
bakeries... if you think professional bakers actually do the Mothra
Stewart micro-measuring dance you're nutz, in fact if you showed up for
work toting a scale you'd be laughed out the back door... they have no
scales either, don't need any stinkin' scale, see reason above (when
baking 12 cupcakes you measure, when baking 1000 cupcakes there's no
need to measure anything... if you end up with 1030 cupcakes, so what).
Spoken like a true mess hall cook who has never run a food business for
profit and who doesn't mind wasting somebody else's money.
Here's what it says in "Professional Cooking" by Wayne Gisslen. "Bakers
generally talk about "formulas" rather than "recipes." If this sounds
more to you like the chemistry lab than the kitchen, it is with good
reason. The bakeshop is very much like a chemistry laboratory in the
scientific accuracy of all the procedures and in the complex reactions
that take place during mixing and baking.
"MEASUREMENT
"*All ingredients must be weighed.* Accuracy of measurement, as we have
said many times, is critical in the bakeshop. Measurement is by weight
rather than by volume measure, because weighing is much more accurate.
Unlike in recipes for the home baker, you will not see a professional
baker's formula calling for 6 cups of flour."
He goes on to talk about the percentage system bakers use.
"BAKER'S PERCENTAGES
"Bakers use a simple but versatile system of percentages for expressing
their formulas. Baker's percentages express the amount of each
ingredient used as a percentage of the amount of flour used.
"To put it differently, the percentage of each ingredient is its total
weight divided by the weight of the flour, multiplied by 100%, or
Weight of ingredient/weight of flour X 100% = % of ingredient
"Thus flour is always 100%. Any ingredient that weighs the same as the
flour is also given as 100%. The following ingredients from a cake
formula illustrate how these percentages are used. (Note that numbers
may be rounded off for practical measuring.)"
He offers examples of the way baker's recipes are written:
"Ingredients Weight Percentage
Cake flour 5 lb 100%
Sugar 5 lb 100%
Baking powder 4 oz 5%
Salt 2 oz 2.5%
Emulsified shortening 2 lb 8 oz 50%
Skim milk 3 lb 60%
Egg whites 3 lb 60%
"The advantage of using baker's *percentages* is that the formula is
easily adapted for any yield, and single ingredients may be varied
without changing the whole formulation. Please remember that these
numbers do not refer to the percentage of the total yield. They are
simply a way of expressing *ingredient proportions.*"
Post by SheldonSuprisingly, even though more food is prepared than is typically
submitted for, very little food gets wasted and the accounting somehow
manages to stay within budget... that's because US Navy cooks are
simply the best trained in the world... certain ENVIOUS assholes may
not like to hear it but it's fact.
U.S. Navy cooks are pretty well trained. Some of them compete in
national and international competitions and generally do well. Hardly
"the best trained in the world."
Post by SheldonThe only scales aboard ship are in the post office and sick bay, there
are none in the galley.
Um, the cookbook says, "Recipes are important. To obtain the desired
results it is advisable to have a copy of the recipe at hand during food
preparation. The recipe should be read several times...before starting
to prepare the food, and directions should be carefully followed."
Says ingredients should be weighed. Period.
Post by SheldonDave, I know with absolute certainty that your
asshole buddy WOPster has never cooked anything, can only write
[volumes of verbiage] about whatever he can extrapolate to suit/sway
from surfing, but with little comprehension of the reality... it's
patently obvious he has no actual hands on cooking experience
whatsoever, NONE... apparently the only thing he excels at is typing
fast, or simply has a LOT of free time.
<LOL> So much for Shecky's "absolute certainty."
Post by SheldonDave, the WOPster is a prevaricator and you swear to it, which makes
you his asshole buddy and flunky. I on the other hand don't need a
cheering section nor do I want one nor would I ever deign to be a
cheering section... I know what I know and am my own man. You are a
FLUNKY, Dave... says a lot about what a small insecure worm of a man
you are.
Now hear this... all hands stand by for a grossly convoluted *ZILLION*
word rebuttal. <G>
So, NO rebuttal...? Shocking, I tell you.
Post by SheldonAhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha. . . .
Sheldon, departing (I'm outta here)
You certainly are.
Pastorio